Sunday, May 24, 2009

Healthy Chocolate Cake with a Secret

Cake.

cake 1
Chocolate cake!

Chocolate cake made without flour, sugar, or dairy. Low carb and gluten-free, of course. Cake made out of a surprise ingredient, one that will make you wrinkle you're nose upon hearing it. This cake is good. So good, in fact, that I had to have a mug of stevia-sweetened pomegranate tea and go to bed, so I'd stop shaving off "test" slices.

You know those feelings that come over you when you play around a bit with a recipe, adding a pinch of this and a tablespoon of that? The nervousness as you put the batter in the oven, the fiddling around with the baking time, the checking and rechecking for doneness? The anticipation as you're cutting the cake, hoping upon hope that's it's not too dry, too mushy, too crumbly?

It's always a rollercoaster of emotion... this time, with a very sweet ending. Why was this particular culinary journey so nerve-wracking?

The cake is made out of black beans. Beans, seriously!

Even if you're the fiercest of bean haters (like I am), you'll fall head over heels for this moist chocolate cake. I haven't have a flour- and sugar-based chocolate cake in a very long time, so my roommates had to confirm this cake's rockstar status. Safe to say they agreed with me, and hungrily polished off the slices I provided for them. Served with a cold glass of almond milk, it was all the more refreshing after a day spent soaking up the Carolina sun.

Happy birthday to my sister, Melanie, and my Dad! This cake is to celebrate their May birthdays. I love you two!
Healthy Chocolate Cake

The best part about this cake is that it's totally budget-friendly. It's basically beans, eggs, and cocoa. That gives you no excuse to not try it, ya hear?

Healthy Flourless Chocolate Cake
Adapted from a recipe at LowCarbFriends

Makes a single 9" layer cake, which can be halved and stacked for the taller cake you see here!

Ingredients:
1-15 ounce can of unseasoned black beans
OR 1 1/2 cup cooked beans, any color
5 large eggs
1 tablespoon pure vanilla extract
1/2 teaspoon sea salt
6 tablespoons unsalted organic butter OR extra virgin coconut oil
3/4 cup erythritol plus 1/2 teaspoon pure stevia extract OR 1/4-1/3 cup honey plus 1 teaspoon stevia OR 1 cup Splenda
6 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
1 teaspoon aluminum-free baking powder
1/2 teaspoon baking soda
1 tablespoon water (omit if using honey)

Mint Chocolate variation:

2 teaspoons mint extract (in place of 2 teaspoons vanilla)

Preparation:
Preheat oven to 325 degrees Fahrenheit. Spray a 9" cake pan with extra virgin olive oil cooking spray, or just grease it with a thin layer of butter. Dust cocoa all over the inside of the pan, tapping to evenly distribute. Cut a round of parchment paper and line the bottom of the pan, then spray the parchment lightly.

Drain and rinse beans in a strainer or colander. Shake off excess water. Place beans, 3 of the eggs, vanilla, stevia (if using) and salt into blender. Blend on high until beans are completely liquefied. No lumps! Whisk together cocoa powder, baking soda, and baking powder. Beat butter with sweetener (erythritol or honey) until light and fluffy. Add remaining two eggs, beating for a minute after each addition. Pour bean batter into egg mixture and mix. Finally, stir in cocoa powder and water (if using), and beat the batter on high for one minute, until smooth. Scrape batter into pan and smooth the top. Grip pan firmly by the edges and rap it on the counter a few times to pop any air bubbles.

Bake for 350 degrees for 40-45 minutes. Cake is done with the top is rounded and firm to the touch. After 10 minutes, turn out cake from pan, and flip over again on to a cooling rack. Let cool until cake reaches room temperature, then cover in plastic wrap or with cake dome (I use an overturned plastic chip bowl). For BEST flavor, let cake sit over night. I promise this cake will not have a hint of beaniness after letting it sit for eight hours! If you are stacking this cake, level the top with a long serrated knife, shaving off layers until it is flat and even. Frost immediately before serving
~57.6g net carbs for the whole cake using erythritol/stevia.
~5.7g net carbs per 1/10th
~125.6g net carbs for the whole cake using honey/stevia.
~12.56g net carbs per 1/10th

Healthy Chocolate Cake

Healthy Chocolate Buttercream Frosting

Makes enough to thickly cover one layer, or fill and frost a halved stacked layer


Ingredients:
1/2 cup (1 stick) unsalted organic butter, softened, OR 7 tablespoons nonhydrogenated shortening
1/4 cup plus 1 tablespoon erythritol, powdered, OR 1/4 cup xylitol, powdered
5-6 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder
2 tablespoons half and half OR coconut milk
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
Pinch of sea salt
Good-tasting pure stevia extract, to taste

Optional addition for a glossy finish:
1 fresh organic egg yolk

Preparation:

Cream the butter in a small bowl until fluffy. Powder erythritol or xylitol in a coffee grinder or Magic Bullet for a minute or two, until extremely fine in texture (reminiscent of powdered sugar). Let sweetener settle in grinder before opening the top. Stir powdered sweetener into butter with a spatula, then beat until smooth. Slowly blend in the cocoa powder (unless you want to redecorate your kitchen), vanilla, and sea salt. Beat in the half and half and egg yolk, if using. Add stevia, starting with 1/16 teaspoon. You'll probably use less than 1/4 teaspoon. Just keep tasting and adjust sweetness to your liking.

~7g net carbs for the frosting, using erythritol

Related content from other blogs:
Purple Velvet Torte @ Elana's Pantry
Spicy Chocolate Bean Cakes @ The Salty Cod
Amazing Black Bean Brownies @ 101 Cookbooks

Leave a comment telling me your favorite kind of cake! Inquiring minds want to know. :)

91 comments:

Keegan said...

That looks so incredibly delicious! What did you use for frosting?

Anonymous said...

Lauren... this looks amazing!!!

What frosting did you use?

P.S. I'm off to make the brownies now! I'll be back to make the cake.

pigpigscorner said...

I can't believe a healthy chocolate cake exists! I've got to try this! yum yum!

Anonymous said...

Lauren,
For the frosting I have both the butter and the Spectrum.... which do you think is better??

Thanks! :)

Sweetdreams from Low Carb

Anonymous said...

This looks marvelous! I can't find erythritol is there a Splenda equivalent?

Magaolimpia said...

Wow! It's looks wonderful!

Kimberly said...

OMG! I am so making this today! How exciting to have a flourless chocolate cake! You can't beat that:)I'm finding that I have a lot of trouble with nuts(nut flours) lately so this is perfect.Can't wait!!

noobcook said...

I love your so rich, yet so healthy chocolate cake. Thanks for visiting me, glad to find your lovely blog :)

Jendeis said...

This looks so delicious!!

Ninette said...

That is one gorgeous cake!

Rachel: untilthethinladysings.blogspot.com said...

You are such a genius! I made a chocolate cupcake recipe once from bean flour and it worked really well- but it was expensive, and the whole time I was thinking it was probably too many carbs. Look how you have fixed that! How do you figure these science-cooking things out!?!? Kudos!

Anonymous said...

That looks beautiful.
A while back, I saw a similar recipe on another blog (I wish I could remember which, because she deserves a world of credit!), but without the butter. And it tasted amazing! The ingredients (which I've slightly adapted) were:
2 cups black beans
4 eggs
3/4 cups sugar (could use erythritol/Stevia instead)
0.25 cups cocoa powder
1 t vanilla
1 tsp baking powder
optional flavors: e.g., espresso powder, cinammon (she used chile I think -- not my cup of fire!)

-- Caddie

Alisa - Frugal Foodie said...

Wow, that looks amazing! I was so surprised when I read the ingredients, who would have guessed?

Cathy said...

Lauren my favorite cake is yellow with chocolate frosting or chocolate cake with white frosting.

Esi said...

This looks incredible! I have heard of using black beans in baking, but haven't tried it myself.

Lorraine @ Not Quite Nigella said...

What a great idea to use beans. I love eating them and am intrigued by the whole idea of using them in a cake!

SarahKate said...

I love it! This looks amazing and I love the bright colours in your photos. Yum!

HEAL ~ BALANCE ~ LIVE said...

I tried it and it's true, no hint of bean after the cake sat overnight. I used all honey to sweeten the cake and I think next time I will double the amount but with frosting it was great. Thanks for this creative recipe!

Anonymous said...

My favorite kind of cake is chocolate (like yours with buttercream frosting). I need to make it soon!thanks!

I also the pudding cake you know the ones that bake with cake on top and a pudding under. I love the lemon but chocolate is great too.
Lexi

Meagan said...

Hey Lauren, that looks great! My mouth dropped when I saw the picture! Experimenting with chocolate and interesting ingredients in baking is certainly fun. Just yesterday my mom ripped an article out of a magazine for sweet potato brownies! I've also seen brownies made with black beans, but this is the FIRST black bean cake I've encountered. It looks so delicious, and my mouth dropped at the picture! (I just had to say that twice). Have you ever considered joining the Daring Bakers?

Jess said...

I made this today and it's to die for!! I crushed almonds for a topping, and that really adds something to it. I'm in love with this cake- extremely rich, and totally satisfying. Thanks again, Lauren!

I gave you credit here: http://minifad.blogspot.com/

Kelly said...

Wow! I am crazy impressed! I am going to try this *very* soon!

Jess said...

I already posted, but as I'm enjoying another heavenly slice of this cake I wanted to return and say so. This is NOT a cake that's good for being made of beans, or for being sugarless... it's just an amazing cake. The beans actually improve a common cake dilemma- flour cakes are often too dry for me, and this is moist and delicious. With the cake being this cheap, I can't think of a reason to ever make a chocolate cake with flour cake again.

THANK YOU! I love your creativity, and

jh said...

Great looking cake. I make brownies that are sort of like this, with black beans. Amazingly moist. My favorite cake, however, is a nice carrot cake. Still haven't figured out a good substitute for cream cheese frosting, however.

jen
Boda Weight Loss Blog

Kelly said...

Rockstar status confirmed:

http://spunkyfamilyjournal.blogspot.com/2009/05/laurens-cake-with-surprise.html

Loved it!!!

divalou said...

what other type of beans could you use? as my town is a bit rubbish and I cant find Black Beans anywhere!

divalou said...

what other type of beans could you use? as my town is a bit rubbish and I cant find Black Beans anywhere!

Lauren said...

Keegan - Thanks! Fixed it. :)

Anon - Fixed the frosting. :) I hope the brownies turned out!

Pigpigs - Hope you get to try it!

Anon - The butter based frosting has much more buttery flavor. Go for it if you can eat dairy.

Anon - Try 1 cup Splenda. :)

Magaolimpia - Thank you!

Kimberly - Sorry to hear you're having trouble with nut flours. Hopefully this cake will treat your tummy well!

Noobcook - Thank you for stopping by!

Jendeis - Thank you!

Ninette - Thanks!

Rachel - I have never tried bean flour--might have to hunt some down! Haha, I just play around with grams of macronutrients on calorieking, and also just make a lot of inedible mistakes until something works out. :)

Anon - Thanks for sharing that recipe! It sounds wonderful.

Alisa - Crazy huh? I would not have believed beans could make a cake this good.

Cathy - Yellow chocolate cake with chocolate frosting is MY favorite cake, too! Will have to work on that.

Esi - Thank you! Yeah, it's hard to believe it until you see it.

Lorraine - I bet these are beans like you have never tasted them. :D

SarahKate - Thank you! The summer sun was out when I took these photos.

Heal ~ Balance ~ Live - Thank you for trying the cake and sharing your results! Glad to hear you had success with it.

Anon - I will have to take a crack at pudding cake! Sounds yummy. I hope this chocolate chocolate cake meets your standards. :)

Meagan - Joining the DB is a great idea! I'll look into it. Sweet potato brownies?! That's almost as crazy as bean cake. :) Try 'em out and let us know how they are!

Jess - Your cake looks fabulous! Thanks so much for trying it out and sharing your results. Topping it with slices almonds is brilliant! :)

Kelly - Thank you! Hope you like it.

Jess - Thanks for the kind words! I am SO glad you are enjoying this cake. It IS so moist because of the beans. Who needs flour when you have real food? :)

Jh - Why do you need to sub cream cheese frosting? Check out my side bar for a sugar-free low carb version. Are you dairy-free as well? Carrot cake is one of my faves, too. :D

Kelly - Oh my, your bundt cake bean cake is beautiful! Thanks for sharing your results. I'm going to try it in a bundt next and maybe pour chocolate glaze on it! Nicely done. :)

Divalou - Try navy beans or red beans. As long as the flavor isn't too distinct, you should be fine!

Lis said...

Well yeah! If I ate like this I sure would feel better! :)

Okay.. so when I finally do go back to find my baking mojo, this is one cake I will try first. I can't get over how wonderful it looks.. excellent photos!

Thanks for the well wishes! Did you see my reply to your question about the recipe archive? Not much help, but I know Blogger has a feature for that.. maybe under lists??

Anyhoo.. thanks again :)

xoxo

Katie said...

Lauren, you have outdone yourself again! I made this cake yesterday and it is delicious! Moist and tasty! No bean-y flavor either. My carb and flour eating husband even liked it a lot! I just had a quick question, when I make cakes with Erythritol I often have them crystalize in the fridge. Do you have any ideas how to keep that from happening? :)Thank you for all of your wonderfully delicious recipes! Keep up your amazing work. :)

Jess said...

Hey, Lauren-

I don't know if you're on Twitter, but either way you may want to add this button to your blogger: http://gotwopointoh.blogspot.com/2009/05/how-to-add-tweet-this-button-after-your.html

That way people can easily Tweet about your posts! :)

-Jess

Carla said...

Thank you! This looks amazing and I plan on making it today! The kids ran over to drool over the screen and ask if I could make it and "fought" about who could eat the most, lol! I used to make bean cookies but kind of forgot about them. I have tons of beans and no way to use them so this is a great thing to do with them!

Lis said...

Me again :)

I couldn't find an email address for you.. would you mind contacting me at lamiacucina AT adelphia DOT net? I've got a couple questions, if you wouldn't mind? :)

Thanks!
xoxo

Sophie said...

Holy coww! You are awesome! Lucky for me, I just happen to love black beans. How moist and decadent is this?! WOW -- I'm blown away!

Mommy Kong said...

I have to admit, I was very skeptical about using the black beans. But I made it anyway, and it was delish! I let it sit overnight as suggested and it's really good. The cake is so moist, it doesn't need the frosting. Good work, Lauren. Any ideas for a white/yellow cake using chick peas?

Cathy said...

This is the bestest cake ever!

Lauren can we have a yellow cake next??? :)

Liz said...

I just want to THANK YOU for all of the hard work you put into this blog!!! Seriously. SOOOOOO appreciated. You reignited the baking-fire that I had so long ago! Since going gluten-free (7 years ago) I quit baking - it was just always a disaster. But I've started using your recipes - and they ROCK! Now I'm inspired to start tweaking and learning how to bake! I am now gluten, casein-free... and low-carb. I love you! seriously!
And I made this cake - simply amazing. My hubby LOVED it (and I made it with lentils, since we didn't have beans - it turned out great!) In fact, he loved it EVEN more since it was made with lentils, since it is good for you! ;)

delectable ditherings said...

Mmmm, really great cake! Thanks so much. Surprisingly easy to make and tasty... didn't taste beany at all. It can be so hard getting cake cravings on a gluten free/sugar free diet but this really hit the spot.

Anonymous said...

Wow, that looks good. But I don't understand what's wrong with using dairy or chocolate in a cake? It's not something you eat a lot of.

Why would you put the cake on an upside down plate? Do you think that it looks better? I think that it makes you look the opposite of smart as you will get crumbs everywhere. That's why the majority of people use plates the way they were designed.

To sum it up, I think you are pretty dumb, but the cake looks good. I like beans.

Sean & Carly said...

I just found your site...and I am in LOVE! One question...would that cake (since it is made of beans) you know...make you gassy? Just a thought?!

Megan Sandoz said...

Just tried the cake, and it was fabulous! Thanks for doing what you do. I recently had to go sugar and dairy free (had to tweak the recipe just a little), and your blog is so helpful and encouraging! Keep it up!

liv said...

I mean this in the nicest possible way....but... are you on crack? Beans? Seriously... Even if I could escape the idea of eating Mexican food for dessert, (which I can't) then WTF is the point of eating dessert if it isn't dessert. This is like a paradox in the space time continuum.... I mean, pasty? Nasty? If this is what life has become then pull out your gun shoot me in the eyeball, shove my body in the oven and broil me back to dust... I protest the mere idea of this recipe.... Alright, that's it! I'm taking back up smoking and eating 3 meals a day from McDonald's because of you... you... butcherer of dreams.

Jackie said...

Made this yesterday. I froze half and frosted the other half with a cocoa and cream cheese frosting.

This has to be one of the strangest recipes I've tried but, IT WORKS!

I did go the long way round as I'm in the UK and could only find dried black beans, so had to go through the whole soaking, cooking bit first but even though my blended beans were not totally smooth, once the cake was cooked you couldn't tell it was anything other than a conventionally made cake. No bits or anything! I'm rambling....I'm still amazed.

Having read your reply to another comment I will try some different beans that I can get tinned.

And ignore the nasty comments. Why do people feel the need to be so rude.

Jackie

Anonymous said...

This recipe was amazing!!! The best recipe I have ever tried. No bean taste at all - instead this rich, deep, decadent dark chocolate flavor. This recipe will be especially enjoyed by people who have discerning palette for gourmet dessert foods.

Anonymous said...

Hi Lauren,
This is so cool. I have been thinking of trying beans as a base for cake or cookies but you did it for me! I just stumbled on you when googling that idea. I like your profile and what you do. My only comment is that erythritol and all of the other sugar alcohol products are not natural or safe. Stevia is safe. Is there a reason you don't use it alone or with other sweeteners that are totally natural?
And to Anon re the plate: I am a photographer by trade and think the upside down plate for a photo was inspired. Cake shows best.
And to Liv: Much of the world has desserts that are made from a bean base. We are just behind.

Healthy Chocolate said...

Have you ever tried these energy Chocolates from Top Form Nutrition ?
They are supposed to help with your metabolism and they also contain Green Tea, Hoodia, Guarana, and B vitamins...

Lauren said...

Katie - So glad you and your husband enjoyed the cake! Every time I use erythritol, I get that effect after refrigerating cakes with erythritol, too. I guess that means the cakes you bake with it are best the day they are made!

Jess - Thank you SO much for the twitter tip!

Carla - I would love to see your recipe for bean cookies! Hope you and the kids enjoyed the cupcakes. :)

Lis - I sent you an email!

Sophie - Hope you like the cake! Your comments are always so thoughtful.

Mommy Kong - I will have a recipe featuring chickpeas soon! Not sure if a yellow cake would be good with beans, just 'cause of the beaniness not meshing well with vanilla! Might have to try it with coconut flour, though. :)

Cathy - Glad you liked it! I'm working on a yellow cake.

Liz - What a nice comment! I appreciate the feedback so much. Good to hear you are baking again! I understand your frustration. So glad you and your husband enjoyed the cake!

delectable ditherings - I am so happy you liked the cake! I agree about it being tough to eat this way at times. Thank goodness for the blogosphere and all the creative cooks outh there. :)

Anonymous - Eat what makes YOU feel the best. :) It is different for all of us!

Sean - Haha, this cake does not cause problems in that way. ;)

Megan - So glad you enjoyed this cake. Would you share your tweaks next time? It's great to hear that you adapted it to suit your needs!

Liv - Thanks for stopping by!

Jackie - What a considerate comment. :) You took the long way with dried beans? Such a trooper! :D Great to hear you can go that route if need be. Thank you for sharing.

Anonymous - High praise indeed! Glad you liked the cake... thanks!

Anonymous - Bean cookies! Inspired. I'll get cracking on those. I don't use stevia by itself in baked goods because the sweetness bakes out, so you have to use so much that the stevia leaves a bitter taste. I formulate my recipes for taste, and gear them towards low carbers/diabetics who need noncaloric sweeteners that do not trigger an insulin response. Erythritol is naturally occurring, found in melons and even our own bodies! We all must use what works for us. :)

Anonymous said...

awesome recipe! i'm newly gluten-free and baking with all those different flours is proving to be a bit of a headache, (a lot of them aren't available in Australia) and i always feel so guilty using almond meal cos it's so high calorie. i didn't tell mum what was in this until she'd tried it and she was completely shocked! i used sugar in the place of stevia as i'm not really familiar with it. i used ten teaspoons, i'll probably use a bit more next time (splenda not being gluten free, in Australia at least). This was an excellent post exam treat to myself, thanks heaps!

Rose said...

BEANS! fascinating! I can't wait to try!! Love your site btw! =)

Cara said...

I've given up artificial sweeteners so I have some erithrytol, but I haven't baked with it yet. You're definitely inspiring me to try it! I also noticed you have a lot of cottage cheese recipes - I am a big fan of using it in creative and different ways too.

divalou said...

i found black beans and made this! Its a bit strange but I think probably the next day it will taste better and i only had baking powder. Maybe using both it would have a better texture. But Still, it is YUMMY!!! :D

Em said...

I just made this last night, and it's amazing! My kids are having it for breakfast. I used black soybeans for a lower carb count, erythritol but no stevia (I prefer a little less sweetness), and butter instead of coconut oil. 1/8 cake has 190 calories, 14.4g fat, 6.8g carbs, 3.4g fiber (leaving 3.4g net carbs), and 8.9g protein.

I was afraid to put it in the fridge because of the erythritol, so I just left it out overnight with a towel over it.

Anyway, it's delicious, and healthful--thanks Lauren!

Ann said...

I made this yesterday, but had to make some changes. I'm new at this and haven't got all my specialty ordered items in the mail yet so I had to go the Splenda route.

Mine was a little dry (not bad, though) which I guessed was from all the cocoa, but otherwise I LOVED it.

I'm writing several recipes to make changes for my taste and run a few test batches. I NEVER would have tried this on my own. Thank you so much. You're such a lovely young lady and so creative.

Anonymous said...

I made this yesterday, using black soy beans (ultra low carb - I use the Eden Foods brand), and I left off the frosting to make this more of a snack cake. I have to say I'm truly impressed - rich, moist, deep complex flavor, but not cloyingly sweet like some chocolate cakes. I'm a baker, and extremely picky, but this makes me HAPPY. Well done!

divalou said...

I made this for the 2nd time today. I halved the recipe, (for portion control!) soaked the beans over night, simmered them for 30mins when I got home, whizzed them up and everything else as per the recipe. Then when all the mixture was ready, i plopped it all back in the blender and whizzed it up again. THEN I chopped up a 74% chocolate bar and mixed the chunks into the cake before baking it for like 45 mins. Once cool, I used the FULL mixture amount for the frosting and OHHH MYYY GOD - FOODGASM. This is dangerously good hee hee.

I bloody love your blog.

Gluten Free Japan said...

First of all, I wanted to say how much I enjoy reading your blog. I'm also a big foodie (graduated college this year, so not a student anymore)but care about nutrition.

I tried your recipe but made a few modifications. Instead of black beans, I used adzuki beans (my blog is in Japanese and adzuki beans are easier to find than black beans over on the island, it seems). I didn't have stevia, so I used cup-for-cup splenda instead. I also omitted the baking soda and increased the baking powder to 1 TBS.

I made mine a layer cake with fresh whipped cream and topped it off with chocolate shavings (I have pics on my blog, so if you can critique my cake, it would be great!)

Tammy said...

Hi Lauren, I made this at the weekend. It tastes AMAZING, and 2 days later is still moist and delicious. I'm a bit confused tho because I made a mistake with the recipe and used 15 ounces of black beans, rather than a 15 ounce can (i'm guessing the 15 ounces includes the water it is in, and is not the drained weight?) and yet despite the fact that I didn't double any of the other ingredients it is still sweet and totally yummy... just twice the size! (and took 1hr to cook through). This has left me a little bewildered... I want to make it again, but am not sure whether to make the same mistake again on purpose!! Any suggestions/explanations would be appreciated.. :)

Anonymous said...

Just curious if you have any recommendations as to what a 'Good-tasting pure stevia extract' would be. All the ones I have tried have a horrible bitter aftertaste. I would truly love to be able to use the stuff, but that one aspect alone makes me shy away from it.

Thanks for the great recipe. I will have to try it soon.

Bridget said...

I love these!! Thank you for a beautiful post.

I've included this recipe in my Ultimate Top 30 Healthy Recipe Posts on the Internet

www.theinternetchef.biz

Thank you for sharing!!
Love,
Bridge.

Bonnie said...

I can't wait to try this - I think I'm going to make it for this weekend's 4th of July festivities!

My favorite kind of cake is angelfood...think you can "low carb" that?! My second favorite is peanut butter and my third favorite is white with buttercream frosting (very sweet). Needless to say, I haven't had any of these for a long time!

Anonymous said...

Hi Lauren, I love your Blog and your recipes. I was thinking about you cake and shaving off the top to make it fit. Well all you have to do is cut it in half and put one part of the half upside down on a concave plate and then place the bottom of the other half on top of the first half and you will still have a nice top to frost. Thank you for the wonderful recipe. Michelle

Natalie said...

WOW. What a beautiful and rich looking chocolate cake! And healthy? Seriously!? If I ever get these ingredients in my pantry I will be using your chocolate cake recipe!

Lis said...

Hi yet once again :)

Just wanted to let you know I did make this cake - my first baking attempt since having to start using insulin.

I was very VERY impressed with the finished cake, bless your cotton socks - thank you!

I have questions though but I don't know if you'll be able to answer them, since I had to tweak the recipe a bit due to the items I had in my pantry.

Okay so I see someone else had a problem with the crystalization due to the erythritol. Do you think leaving the cake on the counter instead of refrigerating it would help this problem?

Also, my biggest tweak was I had to leave the baking powder out since I only had dutch process cocoa in the house. It was a 50/50 guess.. I know either baking powder or baking soda reacts in not such a great way with dutch process cocoa, so I hope I left out the correct one. har! Anyhoo, my cake didn't rise at all.. it was about the height of one of your layers.. I'm guessing it was because I didn't use the soda and/or my baking powder is old.

Finally.. although, like I said, it was deeee licious, it had a bit of a spongey texture, nothing like flourless cakes I've had in the past, and it was quite a bit more dense than the one in your photographs.. mine looked completely solid where yours looks like there are tiny air bubbles in it. Or is that just the photograph? Any clue as to why the texture didn't turn out exactly right?

Regardless of my problems with the cake, I think it's fabulous and that other diabetics should know about it. :) I'm blogging about it this morning, so if you want to have a look-see at how mine turned out, please feel free.

Thanks again, Lauren! xoxo

Lauren said...

Lis - Great to hear you're baking again despite the health challenge! Glad you enjoyed the cake. To address some of the issues:

You're dead on about the erythritol! Leaving it on the counter definitely helps to keep it from crystallizing. It should keep for 2-3 days anyway! Nuking slices of cake individually in the microwave seems to help a bit, too (if you're frozen it for storage).

Someone else told me their cake didn't rise, and I guess leaving out one of the leaveners in the culprit. I'm not too technical with these things to be honest. My Rumford baking powder comes in a tiny tin, so it gets replaced frequently. That might be a strategy to consider! Also, I beat the batter pretty well after mixing everything together. Did you dust the cake pan with cocoa powder so the cake could climb up the sides? Finally, my oven runs quite hot, so try baking the cake at 25 degrees higher to achieve a better rise.

And for the texture issue:
Did you pack the cocoa in the measuring spoon? I tend to scoop it straight from the can with my tablespoon. Did you use 5 eggs?

I hope you get a chance to try the recipe again. You might like it better with the honey, if you can handle the carbs. Erythritol is just so wonderful because of its health properties! You will learn to love these sweeteners more and more as you transition away from the white stuff, Lis. I will be checking out your post!

Lis said...

Thanks for getting back so quickly! So quick, I haven't finished writing up my post yet! hehee

Oh yeah, I'll definitely try this cake again.. keep it out of the fridge, make sure I've got regular cocoa powder and fresh baking soda/powder. I did use 5 eggs and I dusted the pan with the cocoa powder, but didn't pay attention to how far up I went, next time I'll make sure to dust the whole way up. And I too, scoop with the measuring spoon. I'll try a higher temp'd oven too.

Thanks so much sweetie! Gimme another 15 min. or so and the post will be up. ;)

xoxo

Brian Cormier said...

I made this yesterday and can honestly say it's the moistest, most delicious chocolate cake I've ever eaten! Absolutely delicious. It melts in our mouth. Not even a hint of bean taste. Beautiful!

Anonymous said...

Lauren / Lis

I thought the cake in the picture is the full cake cut in half and stacked (leaving effectively half a circle)? in which case it would make sense that Lis's cake would have been 'about the height of one of your layers'? No?

Just wondering!

CDM said...

I just discovered your blog today and love the looks of you black bean cake. I recently made a Vanilla bean cake (after being inspired by The Spunky Coconut). After that success, I am eager to bake again with beans. Looking forward to trying this recipe out. THANKS!!

Progressive Minnesota said...

Do you think I can I use cocoa chocolate bar instead of cocoa powder?

Lauren said...

Brian - I am so glad you enjoyed the cake! That is high praise indeed. :)

Anon - I think you're right. I did the cake in half and stack it!

CDM - I hope you get to try the chocolate version! It is incredibly yummy.

Progressive Minnesota - The added fat content would alter the recipe considerably. I can't guarantee that it would turn out. :) If you do try it, please share your results.

Anonymous said...

Lauren,
I truly want to thank you for all your delicious recipes! I made the cake last night, and I LOVE IT!

Healthy chocolate said...

Thanks for the yummy healthy recipe. Many feels that chocolate is not good for health. But some are good for health like, unsweetened chocolate, bitter-sweet chocolate, raw chocolate bar. One can add grinded cacao beans to smoothie preparations, sweet dishes, tea or beverages, yoghurts, granolas, ice-cream or sweet preparations. One can even make beverage by blending the powdered cacao with hot water or with milk substitutes like hemp milk, multigrain milk, or coconut milk. Also chocolate sauce can be made. To know more on it, refer

Anonymous said...

Great recipe! Thank You!
i added a couple of cups of walnuts and a few Tbs carob in addition to the cocoa and it is just a lovely texture and a delicious cake even without icing , we just sivved a dash of confectioners sugar on top.

Speedwell said...

Lauren and others who have made this cake:

I have already-powdered erythritol (I bought something like fifty pounds of it from a distributor who was clearing it out). How much powdered should I use to equal the granulated amount in the recipe?

Anonymous said...

What a great article, i got a lot of things from here. Thanks!

regards,
Noc

speedwell said...

Successfully made two layers of cake with black soy beans. Tastes awesome, though the chill of the erythritol does come through a bit more than I want it to in bits of the cake. Once kept overnight on the counter in a ziploc baggie, the cool flavor should lessen.

I couldn't figure out how to keep the center of the cake from settling too much. I completely ruined the first layer I tried yesterday, but I think I used dutch cocoa by accident and 350 was not quite the right temp. The trial layer didn't quite hold together, either. I also had used regular black beans instead of black soybeans.

With natural cocoa and fresher baking powder, and using the canned black soy beans, and an oven setting of 325 for a whole hour and ten minutes (!), things seem to have done better.

At least now I can give my diabetic brother the 40th-birthday cake he's been whining about not being able to have for about six months now. Boy, won't he be surprised. :)

chewymama said...

Finally got a chance to make this yesterday. Totally awesome!!! You cant taste the beans at all. My baking soda is old so I didnt get the rise I wanted but the texture was like real cake.

The frosting was very light brown for me? I added a tiny bit of agave for taste and that made it a bit thinner. I still dont know how you got it so thick on yours - I filled it and iced the top but didnt have enough for the sides.

Definitely will make again! I was out of vanilla so I used almond and put in some real vanilla beans and that was great too! I also made the frosting in the food processor.

thanks so much! my kids had a blast having cake for snack :)

Katrina said...

Lauren, I am a 15 year old girl who has MANY food allergies, (and is a health nut!), so I can only eat fruits,vegetable, beans, nuts, and eggs. I was getting SOOOO sick of such a limited diet when I found your blog!! I saw this recipe a week ago, and have already made it four times! It turned out perfectly every time! Thanks so much!

The Fiskeaux Family said...

Wow. We don't have any food allergies, but this cake sounds AMAZING! Mostly, I just want to eat that thick chocolate frosting. :) If you're still answering questions about this post, I have a few.
1. We don't have erythritol or xylitol. How much stevia/powdered sugar/honey would you recommend to replace it in the frosting recipe?
2. How much "good-tasting pure stevia extract" did you add?
3. We have both "regular" and clear liquid stevia. Which of those did you use for the cake and the frosting?
4. Can regular salt be used instead of sea salt? How will that affect the final product?
Thanks for your patience!

Tanya said...

Black beans sound so disgusting but this cake looks so amazing so I have to try this. Thanks for the cool recipe. I'll for sure make it.

Nicole said...

This sounds great, I am excited about baking it for a friend with Gluten allergies! I have a question about using Splenda though - would you replace this with Splenda for Baking? Generally, you use half as much of this product as sugar when replacing it in a recipe so I wasn't sure if I should use 1 cup of Splenda or .5 cup of Splenda. Thanks!

Nicole

Jess said...

As cupcakes, these take 25 mins :)

funmama26 said...

I made the yellow cake this week for my birthday. Put heavy cream whipped with a tablespoon of sugar free pudding in between layers. Covered top layer with chocolate icing and we devoured Boston Cream Pie. My 6 kids all loved it. Baking chocolate version cupcake and butterscotch/cinnamon for breakfast muffins. We'll see how they go over. Thanks for sharing these recipes.

Anonymous said...

so does this count as dessert or vegetarian entree? :-)

Heather said...

Thank you so much for this recipe. I went one step higher and used low carb soy beans (3 net carbs per 15 oz can) and the cake is absolutely amazing. I have really enjoyed your blog and your amazing talent. Thank you so much.

Lauren said...

Heather - Thanks for letting me know how it worked for you! So glad the soy beans were good in this cake. What a great way to up the protein even more! Genius. :)

Anonymous said...

I can't believe how good this cake is and never thought that beans is the key ingredient!
Thanks so much for the recipe, I'm actually going to make one now but I'm going to try it as cupcakes.

123 123 said...

Nice post you got here. It would be great to read a bit more concerning this topic.
By the way look at the design I've made myself Russian escorts

Grace said...

Tried this cake with the frosting (as in the recipe). It is FANTASTIC. The cake is moist and rich! Thanks Lauren.

discomedusa said...

this cake is a winner!
i botched the frosting, but it was still delicious! everyone wanted the recipe, so i had to disclose the secret ingredient. YUM!

Anonymous said...

Lauren, I just want to add my thanks for a great LC chocolate cake! I could not get the frosting right to save my life -- I still don't know what I did wrong -- but the cake was really good with whipped cream. I hope you'll be posting more recipes soon!